Thursday, August 23, 2007

Good New!

Well folks, I have some great news! I went by the condo/apartment unit this morning after work to pick up our mail as I assumed our box might be full. All of the large industrial fans are gone! While the thermometer still read about 98 degrees inside the place, at least it had some oxygen that seeped back in overnight. Made me very happy.  :o)  There are definitely some new spots in the carpet, but I think that (unbeknownst to our landlady) most of those older spots are stains from the chocolate fondue disaster.

I've been thinking about this for a little while now. My poor landlady doesn't know the havoc her  tenants have brought upon that carpet. Now, I'm no expert on the quality of the carpet, but it has stains simply from walking across it in the heavier traffic areas. Even a carpet cleaner and Oxyclean don't take out just the basic dirt. I guess I'm feeling a little guilty that we have "lived"  upon her floor and inflicted food and dirt stains upon it. Here's the other side of the coin, though: it smells like it's had water damage. Most people I know that have had water damage have opted to have the carpet replaced simply because of the mold/mildew smell that harbors in the carpet fibers. Even if our landlady wants to have the carpet stretched back into place and professionally cleaned, I don't think the damage will ever fully be removed from this water episode.

Here's my dilemma. The landlady doesn't know that most of what she sees in the carpet is from us; she thinks it's mold/mildew. What she doesn't know is that professional cleaning isn't likely going to kill the mildew, etc. Do I tell her not to worry about those stains? Or, do I just let her think the carpet has "gone bad" so that she might actually replace it for us? Her home-owner's insurance should cover it. Am I dishonest if I say nothing?

The other  great news is that come what may with the carpet and whatever the carpet guy may or may not decide to do, he's at least coming to take a look at the situation tomorrow. Also, the drywall repair/fix-it guy is coming to redo the hole in the kitchen wall. Yay! We might be able to live in our own place on Saturday. I  don't think I've ever relished the thought of being able  to move into a place and do some cleaning.

Here's another thought: I know my landlady is going to be there at the apartment tomorrow. I also know that she'll probably try to clean everything from the hallway mirrors to the bathrooms if I let her. Am I neurotic for being self-conscious about someone else coming into my home (even if they own it) and cleaning it for me? I find it almost embarrassing.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Pam, you are not neurotic for telling the landlady that you would rather clean things yourself. OR frankly, under the circumstances, she should be very glad to pay for a professional to clean for you.... though it would probably be difficult since it sounds like things have necessarily become quite messy. But I wouldn't want my landlady cleaning for me.
Re the Carpet. Normal wear and tear is part of the cost a landlord has to assume they will have to cover. She should replace that carpet with no questions asked. It will not cost her that much money. I recommend telling her you think it is imperative for health reasons. You'll both be sick from mold and mildew if she doesn't replace that. My estimate is that carpet replacement would be about $5-600. She should do it!
Love, Mim

Gospel.or.Death said...

Not all the facts are here on the table.

First of all, she is having someone who knows what they're talking about re: carpets advise her. He will inspect the carpets. If he passes them, then it's not likely that there will be deep mold in them that will never go away that will make us constantly sick. Frankly, the guy who is inspecting the carpet is probably the same guy that would sell her a carpet, so it's not like the landlady is just trying to save a few bucks here. She's going to do whatever they tell her she needs to do and no more. This is what I have gathered from talking to her anyway. If it turns out that there is some permanent problem with the carpet, and we discover it at some point - though I don't know why we should be more able than the professional to discover it - and it turns out that we are getting sick from it, I guarantee that the landlady will insist on replacing it. But in truth, if the only problem is that it looks a little bad, it is our fault, or rather to be blamed on the fondue disaster.

Secondly, though I said that the landlady is not merely trying to be cheap but following advice, yet I don't doubt she will not spend a penny more than she has to, because when I talked to her last, I asked her if she was going to make some claim in her homeowner's insurance. To this she replied that she likely would not, because it would only raise her premiums.

To me this presents a bit of a puzzle, and I have given thought to it. One possibility is that her deductible makes such a claim not worth it. The other possibility is that she cowers in fear of other human beings and simply allows them to push her around.

I think the first most likely. This tells me that she's not going to be paying much out of pocket for all of this. She told me that the plumbers or whoever who warranteed the pipes will now be paying for some of the damages. I figure that in the end, they'll end up paying for most of it, if not all. If I were running the show, I wouldn't rest until they paid for it all. But running the show I am not.

You see, they balked at paying for it, because that's what people do. People who make a claim against a warranty are almost always told "no" the first time. That probably cuts their costs in half right there, because at least half of all people are so afraid of confrontation that they'll simply take no for an answer and give up and pay for it themselves, though they may grumble about it. This case was no different. Whoever it was replied to our landlady that, sorry, any leaks that are not caught in the first 5 days of the leak are not covered, and this leak has clearly been going on very slowly for some time.

Of course, this is utterly ridiculous, unless of course the people living in the condo have X-ray vision and can see through walls. But I actually heard the landlady's brother, the real estate agent who helped us land this condo, say, "Well, if that's what the warrany says, that's what it says." Let this be a lesson to you. This is how these people save on their costs for putting out shoddy products, because probably half the people react this way. Our landlady did not choose this company to do this stuff to her pipes, the condo-owner's association did. They forced her to have it done, and to let these guys do it. She never chose the company. And it's not like the warranty is a negotiated contract, hammered out and agreed upon by all parties. This was imposed on her.

Yet even the someone with only a tiny sense of justice and a little bit of common sense can see that for them to say that they won't cover it because it wasn't noticed within 5 days is absurd and unjust. The simple fact is, the damage was caused by them, and thus they will pay for it. And if not, there are 150 other condo owners who will probably be having similar battles in the next few years. It would not help their cause to have a lay over and die precedent already set.

So while our landlady doesn't seem to want to call her insurance company to her aid (who would undoubtedly wring every last cent they could out of the warranty company), I contend that she should at least get the association as involved as possible, because we are surely not the only ones this will happen to.

I said more or less all of this to her, and she said I should have been a lawyer. Perhaps I should have.

All of that to say, I haven't decided yet if she has little will to fight or if she simply wants to be a victim in order to have something to complain about. She claims to have lost much sleep over all of this. I can only imagine that she has been quite bullied by these people.

It is little help that her brother, the smart one and undoubtedly her advisor in almost everything that has anything to do with money at all, seems to hold anything in writing to be sacred. "If that's what it says..." But I cannot impose a warranty on you that says that I'm allowed to do crappy work that will destroy your home and not pay for it. It doesn't matter what I impose upon you in writing, if that's what is written. Consider Dad's non-compete agreements. "Sign this or you're fired." It won't hold up in court. It's unreasonable. It's unjust. "Here, I'll sell you this car, but if it blows up on your way out of the dealer's lot, I'm not responsible." Yes, you are. Our country has lost a good deal of its common sense the last few decades, but that much remains.

All of that to say this. She's not going to be excessively cheap, trading our health for a couple hundred dollars. She offered, unbidden, to pay our deductible for us for the hotel stay (though I did mention it to her like this: "There is, however, the matter of a 500 dollar deductible." And then I was simply silent, determined to be silent as long as was needed. Though the answer didn't come instantly, it eventually came: a commitment to pay it. Nonetheless, I didn't out and out ask her to pay for it, but sat back and let her do the right thing, which she did.) Furthermore, I think what truly stresses her out about all of this is that we have been turned out of our apartment. I suppose that that's the chief reason for her loss of sleep. If this is not the case, then she deliberately tried to give me this impression. It may be that she just really wants to be a good landlady, and so now she feels she is not, and rather than being stressed truly about us, she is rather stressed about her own inadequacies, but either way, she is truly concerned for us. And I don't doubt that she feels that this is doubly important, what with me being a seminary student and all.

So I don't think that if the carpet truly needs replacing that she will simply be cheap and not replace it.

However, I would moderate that stance saying that it would be rash to ever underestimate man's greed and thus his willingness to do things on the cheap when it is seen by him to be for someone else, and anyway, the previous carpet was the cheapest that undoubtedly she could get, as was the new tub/shower business that they put in at Christmastime, which we now found out came about because these so-called plumbers had put some stuff in backwards, something which she apparently didn't cry out against then either. So I see a disturbing trend with her. She lets people bully her, and then has no choice but to go the cheap route, since she undoubtedly is not a rich woman.

For my part, the best thing I can do at this point is encourage her to stand up for herself, or appeal to whatever authorities there might be that God has provided for her protection. These are given by God just as surely as are the police. They are given for our good, and we should appeal to them whenever they may be of service. That's what they are there for.

Some would say that it is always simply best to take your licks and walk away, for God sees. Indeed, God does see, which is why he provided means through which we might find justice. Who would not call the police if your next door neighbor was caught in your house stealing your things? Some would say that good Christian wisdom dictates that you say to the thief, "Here, let me help you get that out to your car, what's mine is yours." But that's stupid. Stealing is a sin because what we have been given has been given to us by God. We should treat it so. We should not treat it as if it means nothing to us, because what does that say of God's gift to us? Truly Paul says, "Why not rather be cheated?" But this is what he says to brothers who are disputing with one another; both Christians.

Ghandi's ideas were Hindu, not Christian. You won't catch me walking up to someone and receiving a blow to the head and being happy about it, and you better not steal my stuff.

Justice honors God. God sent Jesus Christ to pay the penalty due our sins in order to pay homage to God's justice, to satisfy it. Justice means so much to God that he sent his only Son to lay down his life for the sake of it.

So Christian ethics does not demand that in this situation, my landlady should simply lay down and let these people trample her. That's not her Christian duty, nor is it ever YOUR Christian duty to do so. If for no other reason than for the sake of the other condo owners who will undoubtedly have the same problems, she should fight in the name of justice, and make them pay as best she can, because they should not be allowed to get away with it.

As you can see, I'm all worked up about it. Maybe she'll replace the carpet, maybe she won't. But she's not, by any means, going to trade our health for money. I am surprised that she is not planning already to replace the carpet, but I don't really care. If it's safe not to replace it, that's fine. She's going to have to replace it anyway when we move out, because we've ruined it (even though anyone would have ruined it, because it's cheap and holds stains like nothing I've ever seen).

Ghee

G4and2Cats said...

Okay - I have kept my mouth shut regarding the carpet thing so far, but now I must speak up! We had a pipe freeze in our townhouse in Ashburn and I came home to an inch of water all over the first floor and we had to move everything into the garage (TV, Piano, Leather Sofa, Book Shelves, etc) and park our cars in the driveway - it was the coldest week of the year with nightly ice storms so our cars were covered with ice and required an hour of scraping each morning. It was terrible! Guys came out to drain the water and a plumer came out to fix the pipe. We had industrial dryers also for several days, but we didn't have to move out luckily since we had two other floors to live on. After all was said and done they restretched the carpet and IT WAS NEVER THE SAME AGAIN!!! I highly recomend asking for new carpet! Restretch jobs are never going to be as good as new carpet. The carpet shrunk from being wet so long and when they removed it from the wall to get the dryers under it the edges tore a bit where they pulle dit out from the baseboards and so when they reinstalled it, the carpet didn't quite fit all they way under the baseboards in ceratin spots, so they did the "best they could" and we had areas that started to pull away after time. And we had a wrinkle down the the middle of the room they claimed couldn't be fixed. So it may seem like all will be better once the carpet gets put back in, BUT it might just be another can of worms. I hate to bring more doom to your already very sad situation, but just be careful... if you have the opportunity to get new carpet (and no time is better than now!) then you should go for it! Hope all works out for you guys!!!

G4and2Cats said...

So my spelling is bad and I made lots of typos... I'm TIRED! but you get the point! :)

Anonymous said...

I am pleased to report that I have just overseen the professional cleaning of the carpet. All is just like new. The padding has been replaced where it was needed, the carpet stretched and retacked down and now finally cleaned. It looks brand new.

Ghee